SomeGuyMusic's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[An Amazing Adventure]

Composition wise it starts to get repetitive. I feel like that just may be the approach to the song which isn't really a technical error but in my opinion makes the song a bit uninteresting after a certain point. I mean that respectfully. The transition at 1:00 felt a bit awkward. It would be really good for a game. It reminds me of a song from a FNAF mini-game. Overall not bad!

burningmagma responds:

Thanks for the constructive criticism! I promise I will add more variety to my songs in the future :^)

[[Chrono Cross] "Ethereal Dreams"]

One thing I think you could work on with this piece is the panning. More things could be panned further in my opinion. The instrument that starts at 3:42 sticks out a bit too much. 2:12 - 2:41 could've been louder. The orchestration and composition are really nice! Very well done!

HoboKa responds:

Thx for the feedback and for scoring :3

[unreal. 2]

I would recommend making the song a bit louder. It sounds a bit too quiet even for an ambient song. I love the composition! Some levels sound like they need to be adjusted but other than that, really well done!

ax1tl responds:

yeah Ableton is quite loud and i never normalized it, will do tomorrow tho!

[[Experimental] TRANQUILITY]

I'm not the biggest fan of the choice of snare at 1:08. I really enjoy the chill vibe of this. I would've liked to hear some more interesting chords and perhaps just a bit more variety but that is also specific to the chord progression.

spicymango002 responds:

the "snare" @ 1:08 is a kick drum
the reason it's not 3+ minutes is so it would feel like it was dragging out or too repetitive.
I'm not super creative with chords.
But thanks for the comment and for listening to my song, it means a lot! :)

[Abyss Walker]

I'm not the biggest fan of how the vocals were mixed in. If they sounded more in the background, they would sound better imo. Some parts I think they can stay where they are though such as 1:20. Another thing is the beginning sounds cluttered so I recommend adjusting your levels. What sounds like a bell in the beginning immediately gets drowned out by the pads. It would sound better, in my opinion, if the bell was actually more prominent than the pads. At 0:35 the vocals sound like they're overtaking to the point where I can't really hear the progression of the pads. I recommend turning the pads up or turning the vocals down. Some violins in this would be nice. The ending wasn't all the satisfying in my opinion. I really like the chord progression! As far as comp goes it doesn't sound bad.

TopMaru responds:

I actually really appreciate this detailed feedback, thank you! I've still got a lot to learn so everything helps me immensely.

[Dimension flex!]

The song is loud but it lacks a lot of texture and some parts just sound empty. The drops feel very lacking due to a lack of texture. I recommend more layering and perhaps adding more variety to your composition. That and adjusting your volume in some parts. Maybe add some quieter bits like when the piano plays. Maybe take the snare out sometimes and switch up the beat more often.

RealMaxWell2 responds:

Thank for the advice!

[RUSH]

The beat that starts at 0:17 starts to get really repetitive so I recommend switching it up a bit. I feel like a different approach could've been better for this song imo. I like the violins that come in later but they sound kind of muddy. The piano later on sounds a bit too loud. I really like the glitch effect at the end as well as the other ones. This a lot more hip hop than dubstep.

elemode responds:

tysm for the feedback! Cleaning that stuff up rn! Thanks for listening!!

[ELEPS & Hookington - Watch Out (ROBBY WOW Remix)]

I dig this ngl. Your snare is very weak at 0:58. As a matter of fact some of your snares could be a bit punchier and I would recommend turning your kick down just a bit. Composition on the drop is sick asf though. I would also recommend not repeating the intro at 1:24. Maybe switch it up just a bit. The song sounds like it lacks texture overall and clarity in the drop. Your synth at 1:24 sounds a bit muddy. With a lot of things in this song it sound like you almost had it but you didn't push it far enough. For example, at the beginning of the second drop. That riser could have been more intense imo.

IIROBBYWOWII responds:

Thanks for the feedback!